Die Studie von Darius Leszcynski (2002)


In dieser finnischen Studie mit menschlichen Endothelzellen, die elektromagnetischen Feldern wie von Mobiltelefonen ausgesetzt waren, wurden im Laborversuch nach einer Stunde Einwirkungsdauer Veränderungen der Proteinaktivität festgestellt, welche als Stressreaktionen gedeutet werden können. Falls derartige Wirkungen auch im lebenden Organismus auftreten sollten, könnten diese von gesundheitlicher Bedeutung sein und beispielsweise die Entwicklung die Durchlässigkeit der Blut-Hirnschranke erhöhen. Dies wiederum könnte zu Kopfschmerzen, Müdigkeit oder Schlafproblemen führen.

Sowohl die Autoren selbst als auch andere Experten können jedoch keine Aussage machen, ob diese im Labor gefundenen Ergebnisse überhaupt auf den ganzen Menschen übertragbar sind und sie sehen daher keine Veranlassung vor dem Gebrauch von Mobiltelefonen zu warnen oder eine Herabsetzung der Grenzwerte zu verlangen.

Auf dieser Seite sind folgende Artikel dazu:

 
1. Eine Beschreibung der Studie, als Tagungsbericht von dem Biochemiker Dr. Franke (Universität Münster) von dem 24. Jahrestreffen der Bioelectromagnetics Society (BEMS), auf welcher D. Leszcynski seine Untersuchungen vorgestellt hat.

Studie zur Blut-Hirn-Schranke von Lesczynski

Besondere Beachtung fand ein Beitrag von Leszczynski (Helsinki, SF). Dem Titel seines Vortrages nach hat er auf molekularer Ebene einen Mechanismus aufgeklärt, auf dem die Blut-Hirn-Schranke (BHS) durch Einwirkung von Mobilfunkstrahlung beschädigt wird. Auch seine bereits in den Medien (BBC, Bild der Wissenschaft) intensiv diskutierte Publikation in „Differentiation“ (Differentiation 2002, 70:120- 129) suggeriert zunächst eine richtungsweisende Aufklärung durch die Arbeit dieser finnischen Gruppe.
Leider beschränkt sich Leszczynski in seinen Aussagen jedoch ausschließlich auf Hypothesen und Postulierungen über den Einfluss der beobachteten Effekte auf die Blut-Hirn-Schranke. Interessanterweise handelt es sich bei den vom ihm verwendeten EA.hy926 auch nicht um Zellen, welche die BHS repräsentieren, sondern vielmehr um Zellkulturen aus der Nabelschnur. Die Morphologie, also das äußere Erscheinungsbild der Zellen auf den von ihm präsentierten Photos, hat auch keinerlei Ähnlichkeit mit der typischen Spindelform von BHS-Endothelzellen. Auch auf deren wichtigste Eigenschaft, die Schrankenbildung durch sogenannte „tight junctions“ geht er nicht ein.
Bei Exposition (GSM 900; 2W/kg; 1h) mit Mobilfunkstrahlung findet Leszczynski unter nichtthermischen Bedingungen eine Steigerung der Phosphorylierung des Hitzeschockproteins 27 (hsp27) und eine erhöhte Expression der Proteine hsp27 und p38-map-kinase. Die in seinem Vortrag gezeigten Fotos indirekter Immunfluoreszenzfärbungen konnten jedoch nicht von diesem Ergebnis überzeugen. Auch die von ihm gezeigte Induktion von „Stress-Fasern“ genannten Aktinfilamenten in den Zellkulturen war anhand der Fotos schwer nachzuvollziehen.
Ferner berichtete er von einem Screening, in dem mittels 2D-Gelektrophorese und Westernblots über 1200 verschiedene Signale erhalten wurden, unter diesen über 300 von Phosphoproteinen deren Phosphorylierungsgrad nach Mobilfunkbestrahlung verändert war. Von diesen konnte er bisher nur eines, das oben genannte hsp27, identifizieren. Ein Zusammenhang dieser Beobachtung mit eine Schädigung der Barrierefunktion der BHS wird, wie er wiederholt betonte, bisher nur vermutet. Auf eine Eignung der EA.hy926 Zellkultur als Modell für die BHS ging er weder in seinem Vortrag, noch in der anschließenden Diskussion ein. Eine neue Faktenlage bringt die Arbeit daher bezüglich der Beeinflussung der Blut-Hirn-Schranke durch elektromagnetische Felder nicht.

Komplettes Original im Newsletter 2/2002 der Forschungsgemeinschaft Funk (pdf, 1,9 MB)

3. Die Abstracts der Studie, wie sie auf dem 24. Jahrestreffen der Bioelectromagnetics Society (BEMS) in Quebec (Kanada) vom 24. - 27.06.02 vorgestellt wurde

PHOSPHORYLATION OF HSP27 - THE MOLECULAR MECHANISM FOR MOBILE PHONE RADIATION-INDUCED INCREASE IN BLOOD-BRAIN BARRIER PERMEABILITY

D. Leszczynski. Bio-NIR Research Group, Radiobiology Laboratory, STUK - Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority, Helsinki, Finland

BACKGROUND:
The question of whether mobile phone radiation (RF-EMF) is hazardous to health remains unanswered. In earlier study (1) has been demonstrated that the 1-hour non-thermal exposure of human endothelial cell line EA.hy926 to SAR of 2W/kg (900MHz GSM signal) leads, among others, to:
i) transient increase in phosphorylation of hsp27 stress response protein, which was prevented by SB203580, a specific inhibitor of p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (p38MAPK), and
(ii) transient changes in protein expression levels of hsp27 and p38MAPK. Phosphorylated hsp27 has been shown to regulate, among others, cell apoptosis - due to inhibition of the proteolytic activation of pro-caspase-9, and stability of stress fibers - due to increasing polymerization of actin. The latter, when occurring in endothelial cells lining brain's capillary blood vessels, might be of critical importance for the functioning of blood-brain barrier because stabilization of stress fibers was shown to cause: (i) cell shrinkage, leading to opening of spaces between cells, (ii) increase in the permeability and pinocytosis of endothelial monolayer, (iii) increase information of apoptosis-unrelated blebs on the surface of endothelial cells, which may obstruct blood flow through capillary blood vessels, (iv) stronger responsiveness of endothelial cells to estrogen and, when stimulated by this hormone, to secrete larger than normally amounts of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) which could, in endocrine manner, stimulate de-differentiation and proliferation of endothelial cells leading to the associated with proliferative state - cell shrinkage and unveiling of basal membrane.

HYPOTHESIS:
Based on the above, has been proposed (1) that: the activation (phosphorylation) of hsp27 by mobile phone radiation might be the molecular mechanism regulating (i) caspase-9-dependent apoptotic pathway and (ii) increase in blood-brain barrier permeability, which has been observed in some animal experiments.

OBJECTIVE:
To determine whether physiological responses of endothelial cells, which are associated with the hsp27 phosphorylation and might affect permeability of blood-brain barrier (stability of stress fibers, cell size/shape), occur in the mobile phone radiation exposed cultures of human endothelial cells.

METHODS:
Human endothelial cell line EA.hy926 cells, grown on microscope cover slides, were exposed for 1h to 900MHz GSM signal at an average SAR of 2W/kg. Temperature of cell cultures remained throughout irradiation period at 37+0.3 o C thus the effects reported here are of non-thermal nature. Cells on cover slides were fixed either immediately or 1h after the end of irradiation. The expression of hsp27 was determined by indirect immunohistochemistry in order to confirm that the cells respond to irradiation in the same way as in the previous study (1). The appearance of cells (size, shape) and stabilization of stress fibers was determined by staining of the cells with phalloidin that was labeled with fluorescent-dye (AlexiaFluor).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
As expected, 1h exposure of cells to mobile phone radiation increased expression of hsp27. However, in order to increase hsp27 expression by heat shock was required 3h incubation of cells at 43 o C (1h exposure had no effect). This observation, together with the measurements showing that temperature of medium was throughout RF-EMF exposure period at 37+0.3 o C, suggest that the observed here effects are of non-thermal nature. The stability of stress fibers, as determined by the pattern of staining with phalloidin-AlexiaFluor, increased after 1h irradiation and did not decline during the 1h of post-irradiation incubation (Figure 1 A,B,C). Induction of the stability of stress fibers caused cells to shrink. As seen in Figure 1 A,B,C - brightly stained cells with stabilized stress fibers rounded-up and appeared as smaller than the adjacent non-stained cells. These rounded-up, stress fibers expressing, cells contacted in-between only through thin pseudopods (Figure 1D,E,F). The observed hsp27-related increase in the stability of stress fibers and caused by it changes in cell shape and size of EA.hy926 cells support the proposed above hypothesis that the hsp27/p38MAPK stress signaling pathway might be the molecular mechanism regulating mobile phone radiation-induced permeability of blood-brain barrier. Furthermore, the possible RF-EMF-induced breakage of the blood-brain barrier, if occurring repeatedly over a long period of time might become a health hazard because of the possible extra-capillary accumulation of molecules that might cause brain tissue damage.

Reference: Leszczynski D. & Joenväärä S. (2002) Differentiation, in press


Das Original ist auf Seite 6 und 7 der Meeting abstracts (269 Seiten pdf, 2.6 MB)

3. Der Vorbericht zur Studie in der BBC vom 19.06.02

Fresh fears over mobile phones

A major study into the safety of mobile phones has concluded that they may affect the health of people who use them. Research carried out by scientists in Finland suggests radiation from mobile phones causes changes in the brain.
It is the first time that scientists have looked at the effects of mobile phone radiation on human cells rather than those of rats.

Scientists from the Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority found that exposing human cells to mobile phone radiation damaged the blood-brain barrier - a safety barrier in the body that stops harmful substances in blood from entering the brain.

They discovered that the exposure caused the cells in blood vessel walls to shrink which enabled molecules to pass into brain tissue.

Lab tests

Professor Darius Leszcynski, who carried out the study, said the results came from laboratory tests on human cells and that further research was needed to see if the same effect actually happened in humans.
But speaking to BBC News Online, he said: "The blood-brain barrier has been shown to be affected by radiation in animal studies.
"There is a lot of uncertainty about whether this happens in humans. We have shown some biological effects."
Prof Leszcynski said these changes could have a serious impact on a person's health if they were found to happen in humans.
"If it did happen it could lead to disturbances, such as headaches, feeling tired or problems with sleeping. A study by a Swedish research group even suggested it could lead to Alzheimer's disease."

However, he added: "It is important to remember that our study has been done in the laboratory where we can detect even the smallest changes. "We cannot say whether it happens in humans. We need further study looking at real people to see if the blood-brain barrier is affected.
"What is happening in the human brain is an absolute enigma. We don't know at all."

'Still safe'

Prof Leszcynski said mobile phones were still safe to use.
"At the moment, there is no scientific support for introducing any sort of limitation either on use of mobile phones or setting new safety limits.
"There is no need because we don't have any science to support it. All the guidelines in place at the moment are fine."
Prof Leszcynski will present his findings at a conference in Quebec, Canada, next week.
He said a study by French scientists, which will also be presented at the conference, found similar results in rats.
Dr Michael Clark, science spokesman at the National Radiological Protection Board, said the research did not show any impact on people's health.
"This is demonstrating a biological effect in cells in the lab."
Speaking to the BBC, he said: "It doesn't relate to a health effect. You can't go from a biological effect in a Petri dish to say that's a health effect."
He added: "The authors themselves are saying that this doesn't mean that mobile phones are unsafe or the guidelines are wrong."

The Consumers' Association said there was still insufficient evidence to say whether or not mobile phones were safe.
A spokesman said: "At the moment, it's too soon to reach a definitive verdict on health risks from mobile phones, but neither has research given it the all clear."
The National Consumers' Council said mobile phone users were reaching their own conclusions about the risks.
"The people who feel that mobile phones are very important and essential in their lives would attach less weight to this new information than those who are already concerned about the risk," said a spokeswoman.
More than 40 million people in Britain have mobile phones, many of them children.

Government studies

Two years ago a government inquiry led by Sir William Stewart concluded that mobile phones posed no provable health risk.
But its report urged caution over the use of mobile phones by children until more was known about their impact on health.
In January, a new £7.4 million research programme was announced, backed by the government and the mobile phone industry, to be managed by an international committee of experts led by Sir William.
The programme includes 15 studies which will seek clear conclusions about the health hazards of mobile phones, in particular fears of an association between mobile phone radiation and brain cancer.
The main purpose of the research will be to see whether "subtle biological changes" already known to be caused by mobile phones pose a risk.

Link zum Original

Mehr Information zur Blut-Hirn-Schranke auf dieser Homepage

 

 


Navigation zu
  dieser Seite:
        
Homepage Elektrosmoginfo
Menüseite: Wirkungen elektromagnetischer Felder
  Einzelne Studien
    Die Studie von Darius Leszcynski (2002)
 
Zuletzt geändert: 03.12.02